Lindsay Krueger
Caldwell ISD - Instructional Technology Coach
Capstone:
Synthesis Digital Learner/Leader
COVA Reflection and Application:
At times it feels like I have just begun this journey in the ADL program and now I realize I am in the final stretch. When I first applied for this program I had butterflies and felt very anxious. I discussed these feelings many times in my blog posts. Imagine a woman my age going back to school when I am closer to the side of retirement! I would not have taken the leap if it weren’t for the amazing support of my husband. One thing he said that has resonated with me is “You will never regret getting an education, but you will regret not.” After he said those words to me, I dove right in and never looked back and I am so glad that I did!
Last summer marked the beginning of my journey in the ADL program and the introduction to the idea of COVA - Choice, Ownership, and Voice in Authentic Learning (Harapnuik, 2018). Initially, I was unfamiliar with this concept but began the journey of exploration and discovery. The COVA approach, which emphasizes choice, ownership, voice, and authentic learning experiences, aligns perfectly with the applied digital learning concept. As an educator, I had always valued granting my students some level of autonomy in their projects, yet I hadn't fully comprehended its advantages until delving deeper into COVA theory. The COVA learning approach can enhanced my experience in this program by shifting the focus from traditional, one-size-fits-all teaching methods to a more personalized and self-directed learning journey. With COVA, I had the freedom to choose what to learn, how to learn it, and the resources I wanted to use.
​
My initial response to having the freedom to take ownership was in the first course creating an ePortfolio. It was a bit overwhelming at first. I struggled to design my projects without predefined structures. I appreciated the example links that were given on Dr. Harapnuik's ePorfolio but still having that much freedom was mind-boggling, the possibilities were endless. I wasted so much time playing with templates and design that I had to draw myself back to the real requirements of the project. Yet, as I embraced the freedom to take ownership, I began to value the opportunity to personalize my work, shaping it into something meaningful for my career. It has empowered me to create projects that resonate with my interests and career goals while taking control of my learning journey. My ePortfolio is a collective learning platform that has offered an invaluable opportunity for me to capture my progress and projects over time, foster my growth, and help me become a better educator. I have taken a sense of ownership in creating it. When I look back on my learning, I find that I have changed my outlook on learning in many ways. It is something that I am very proud of and hope to continue after the ADL program. I also realized that it will always be a work in progress and will constantly change. “Tell me, and I’ll forget. Teach me, and I’ll remember. Involve me, and I’ll learn” (Franklin, n.d.).
​
During the initial course, along with creating an ePortfolio, we were assigned the task of developing an innovation plan aimed at leveraging technology to enhance student engagement and facilitate meaningful learning experiences. Recognizing the potential of COVA principles in transforming education, I wanted to ensure that my students not only grasped the concept but also understood its profound impact on their learning journey. With this in mind, I envisioned integrating COVA principles into my graphics design courses through the implementation of ePortfolios. The idea of my innovation plan revolved around teaching students strategies to utilize technology effectively, and also foster engagement and ownership of their learning. By incorporating ePortfolios into my curriculum, I was able to provide students with a platform to showcase their creativity, reflect on their learning experiences, and take ownership of their educational journey. Not only would ePortfolios allow my students to showcase their design projects in a digital format, but they would also provide a space for self-expression and reflection. By embracing ePortfolios as a tool for authentic assessment, students would develop a deeper understanding of the creative process and its relevance to the real world. Through this innovative project, I am able to empower students to take ownership of their learning, embrace creativity, and prepare them for an always changing digital world.
​
Promoting change in my classroom was easy. I do it daily but embracing the idea of promoting change in my district initially evoked apprehension. I doubted my ability to produce change within my school, let alone across the district. Nevertheless, I've adopted a continuous learner's mindset and plan to instill this mindset, along with the principles of COVA, not only in my students but in my colleagues as well. After I integrated the ePortfolio initiative into my classroom, I expanded it and have been working with our CTE department to branch to other content areas. Despite facing some resistance, particularly from the CTE department, they became more receptive to the idea once I showed them examples of my student's work and they realized that this is something that once taught the students can do on their own. My attitude toward leading change has evolved throughout this program. Initially apprehensive, I now recognize the value of innovation and am committed to implementing authentic change within my organization.
​
Realizing that growth only occurs when you step out of your comfort zone is pivotal. Comfort zones provide a sense of security, shielding individuals from the uncertainties of change. However, it's within discomfort that true progress is made. Whether for students or educators, remaining within the confines of what feels safe withholds development. Embracing discomfort is like exploring new ideas and facing challenges to help you get better. As Thomas and Brown state,"Change motivates and challenges. Change forces us to learn differently" (2011). It's through these experiences that individuals stretch their limits, improving their skills and expanding their capabilities. Getting better at things requires being okay with feeling uncomfortable and dealing with things you don't know because that's how you truly grow.
​
The COVA approach and Creating Significant Learning Environments (CSLE) are foundational concepts that deeply resonate with my learning philosophy but through slightly different views. Both COVA and CSLE prioritize learner autonomy and meaningful learning experiences, which align with my beliefs as an educator. The COVA approach aligns with my philosophy because it places learners at the center of the educational process. I believe that students thrive when they have the autonomy to make choices about their learning, take ownership of their learning experiences, and have a voice in the classroom. Similarly, Creating Significant Learning Environments (CSLE) discusses the importance of designing learning experiences that are relevant and engaging. This concept aligns with my belief that education should extend beyond the acquisition of knowledge. It should foster critical thinking, creativity, and real-world application of skills. CSLE promotes curiosity and collaboration, and it also challenges learners to think deeply. This aligns with my philosophy that education should be meaningful and reflective.
​
Reflecting on my experience in the ADL program using COVA + CSLE principles, it clarifies what I understood about students' educational needs. At the beginning of my teaching career, I worked with kindergarten students. It became clear to me that for students to grasp concepts fully, they needed hands-on engagement in their learning process. One memorable project was the "egg to chick" unit, where I introduced an incubator, allowing students to witness firsthand the transformation process. Through my involvement in the ADL program, my perspective on learning and teaching has slightly shifted. The introduction of the COVA approach challenged me to reevaluate traditional ways of education and embrace a more student-centered approach. As a result, my learning philosophy has evolved to prioritize learner autonomy and creating meaningful learning experiences. I've gained insights into the significance of choice, ownership, and voice in student learning. I have come to understand that learners are more engaged when they have the freedom to make choices about their learning, take ownership of their educational journey, and have a voice in the classroom. This has led me to prioritize creating a learning environment that empowers students to be active participants in their own learning, rather than just learning the information. I now see technology not just as a tool for delivering content, but as a way to enhance student engagement and promote collaboration. As I continue to develop my educational philosophy, I hope to better accommodate the diverse needs and learning styles of my students.
​
An unexpected requirement that we had when starting this program was to form a peer collaboration group. Initially, I assumed I could handle the coursework alone, without realizing how much I would come to depend on these ladies. I am grateful to the program for pushing me out of my comfort zone and prompting me to establish these valuable connections. I was blessed to be able to form a strong collaborative group during the first course, and we have remained together throughout. We were excited to add another member in the last session which proved to be very beneficial to our group. Through this collaboration, I have developed lasting friendships, enhancing my overall experience in the ADL program. I was able to work with these ladies on a first podcast which resulted in a successful project. These ladies have been my rock and have made this experience so much better!
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
Knowing what I now know about the COVA approach, I plan to integrate it into my teaching practices to create significant learning environments in my organization. This will involve designing authentic assignments that provide students with choice, ownership, and voice in their learning. By allowing students to select topics, explore their interests, and demonstrate their learning in creative ways, I plan to give a sense of ownership and engagement in the learning process. Through this program, I was able to understand how to develop a more effective professional learning environment. This had helped prepare me for my current position as an Instructional technology coach. With the help of this course, I plan to prepare my colleagues for the COVA approach and CSLE by providing training, resources, and ongoing support. This will involve workshops and professional development that will include the COVA and CSLE approaches, as well as practical strategies for implementation. I will also encourage collaboration to create opportunities for colleagues to share their ideas and learn from one another.
I anticipate that there will be challenges along the way but promoting a more student-centered approach will take time and effort to achieve. Some of these challenges may include resistance to change, time constraints, a lack of resources, and assessment challenges. Overcoming these challenges requires effective communication, ongoing support, and collaboration among educators and stakeholders. Providing support, sharing success stories, and offering practical strategies for addressing barriers can help my colleagues accept the COVA framework and significant learning environment approach. Despite these challenges, I am committed to advocating student autonomy and promoting meaningful learning experiences.
​
In conclusion, the journey in the ADL program has been one of self-discovery, growth, and transformation. From the initial course to these last few it has reshaped my approach to teaching and learning. As I continue on this journey, I am committed to creating environments that empower learners to have autonomy and promote a passion for lifelong learning. COVA, with its emphasis on choice, ownership, and voice, will remain an important part of my educational philosophy.
References:
​
Dweck, C. (2016). Mindset: The new psychology of success. New York, NY. Penguin Random House.
​
Franklin, B. (n.d.). "Tell me and I forget, teach me and I may remember, involve me and I learn". Retrieved from https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/authors/b/benjamin_franklin.html
​
Harapnuik, D., Thibodeaux, T., & Cummings, C.. (2018). Choice, Ownership, and Voice through Authentic Learning COVA. Creative Commons License.
​
Thomas, D., & Brown, J. S. (2011). A new culture of learning: Cultivating the imagination for a world of constant change. Lexington, KY: CreateSpace.
Embracing Change:
Embracing change is essential for personal growth and adaptability. To accept change you have to be open-minded and flexible in the face of new opportunities and challenges. By embracing change, we can break free from our comfort zones, discover new ideas, and develop resilience. Instead of resisting change, we should embrace it, this leads to transformative experiences and positive outcomes.
​
"If you are entrusted with bringing about change, you likely possess the knowledge needed to advance your organization, and you might have a plan—but knowledge is not enough. You have to bring yourself to each interaction in a deeply authentic way. People don't care how much you know until they know how much you care." — Doug Conant
​
I was first introduced to the idea of organizational change this past summer in my first Applied Digital Learning ADL course, Disruptive Innovation. As I was learning about being innovative in my organization I was also introduced to the use of portfolios, a digital tool that gives students autonomy and a way to reflect on and improve their learning. As I considered an innovation plan that I could utilize in my current role, I found that implementing eportfolios in my current classes would be beneficial where I could use my new role as an Instructional Coach to continue this implementation across multiple content areas.
Reflecting on Change:
Reflecting on my ePortfolio innovation plan, I've initiated several stages thus far, including the planning, research, development, and implementation stages. It all began with the idea of integrating ePortfolios into Career and Technology Education courses in my district. From there, I was able to engage in comprehensive research, examining various methods and approaches so that I could effectively implement ePortfolios in the high school classroom setting. This phase involved reading numerous articles, analyzing case studies, and exploring innovative learning practices. I used all this newfound knowledge to write a literature review, which provided an overview of the benefits, challenges, and best practices associated with using ePortfolios in educational settings.
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
With the valuable insights from the research phase, I began the development stage of my plan. I was able to take a hands-on approach after being assigned to create my own ePortfolio. I dived into this process to gain firsthand experience and insights into what it takes to create an eportfolio. This proved to be most beneficial in the ePortfolio development and implementation stages. I was able to put myself in the shoes of my students and find out firsthand what their challenges would be and how best to instruct them on creating their own eportfolio.
As my understanding deepened and my confidence grew, I put my vision and strategy into a
formal proposal that I presented to my stakeholders to gain their support. I decided to begin
small. I would propose to begin the implementation stage in my Graphic Design classes and
once this pilot course was over, I could fine-tune my strategies using the feedback of my
students and colleagues and expand to more content areas in my district. But I first had to find
my “Why” in order to capture the attention of my audience. In my proposal document, I not
only outlined the purpose behind integrating ePortfolios but also provided a clear roadmap
and timeline for my implementation. Stating my "why" was an important process, but it was
just the start of promoting a change in my organization. I learned strategies like the
4 Disciplines of Execution and the Influencer Model to improve my project's execution. These
frameworks helped in achieving my goal and improving the performance of my students.
​
By using this knowledge I was able to gain the approval of my stakeholders and I already had access to many resources. I then began the implementation phase of my plan. This past August, I introduced my Graphic Design students to the idea of ePortfolios. I started by showcasing my own eportfolio along with other samples. I felt this helped them buy into the idea that I was not asking them to do anything that I hadn’t done.
Over the next few weeks, my students were encouraged to explore various layout designs, experiment with multimedia elements, and create an eportfolio that was unique to them. They are now able to use these eportfolios to reflect their unique skills, achievements, and aspirations, and showcase them in an organized way. This in turn gives my students autonomy and ownership over their learning journey. Throughout the implementation process, I have asked for student feedback so that I can refine my approach based on their insights and experiences.
Additionally, I aligned outcomes using the Understanding by Design (UbD)Framework. This helped to emphasize starting with the end goal and working backward to plan activities. I had to decide where I wanted to see my students end up. To make it clearer, I created a Fink's Three Column Table to carefully show my planning goals, activities, and assessments to ensure that what students learn matches what I wanted them to achieve. Later in my ADL program, I created an Action Research Plan and I was able to revisit my research where I was able to revise it with all the new knowledge I had acquired. With the help of this program, I was able to put together a Professional Learning course for teachers to promote the use of eportfolios. I am excited to be able to present this to my colleagues this summer in our Technology Professional Development in July!
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
​
Where I Am Now:
In my journey of implementing ePortfolios, I began with thorough research, literature, case studies, and innovative learning strategies. This helped tremendously in the ePortfolio plan process and provided firsthand experience and insights into challenges and best learning practices. This gave me a better understanding of my student needs. Involving students from the start empowered them to take ownership of their learning journey. Students were also included in the feedback process for implementation improvement.
Currently, I am in the phase of finishing my initial implementation and refining my innovation project. While the core framework and key components are in place, some specific tasks and results require completion before the project can be fully reviewed. First, it's crucial to evaluate the final product, evaluating not only the content but how it is organized and assessed. Documenting along the way was important for this. At the end of this implementation phase, I will request feedback from my students and colleagues. This will play a pivotal role in refining my innovation plan. Receiving feedback from students and educators will help me find areas that may not have worked well, as well as things that did work. This will provide guidance and help me to refine the implementation process for the future. Preparing for next year's implementation involves reflection and refinement of the ePortfolio process. I can analyze the successes and challenges of the current implementation, adjusting strategies and resources as needed.
​
Moving Forward:
While the ePortfolio implementation process has shown promising results, there are areas
where improvements could enhance its effectiveness. Specifically, time management is an
area that needs to be refined. Considering the experience gained through implementing
eportfolios in my class this year, there are several adjustments I would make to my curriculum.
These include establishing clearer milestones and checkpoints to track progress. Another area
that needs to be revised is clearer communication of expectations. I would also have clearer
expectations of what is expected for the reflection portion of the ePortfolio. In the future
a set day for students to work on adding to their eportfolios each week. This would provide
students with a better understanding of project requirements, minimizing misunderstandings
and increasing productivity. These key lessons from my pilot implementation have been valuable.
I've learned how important it is to be flexible and resilient when facing challenges. By integrating
these lessons into future implementations, the ePortfolio process can continue to evolve and
improve, enhancing student engagement and learning outcomes.
​
As I prepare for further phases of my innovation plan, communication with my colleagues and
stakeholders will be vital. This will involve presenting my project to the department heads and
then presenting my professional development course to the CTE educators in my district this
summer. To further promote and communicate my innovation project, emphasizing the benefits
and relevance of ePortfolios in enhancing student learning and showcasing skills will be key to gaining buy-in from my colleagues. To do this I will use sample eportfolios from my current class to showcase the benefits of using them for students and the value of ePortfolios in preparing students for future career pathways and real-world learning opportunities.
Final Thoughts:
Starting an innovation plan in my organization was definitely a rewarding process, but it required careful planning and implementation. Anyone can create a positive change. To do this begin by identifying the "why" or positive change within the organization that could benefit from an innovation. Completing research to understand the change that you want, and gather insights from existing literature, case studies, and effective teaching practices is vital. It is also important to gain the support of your stakeholders early on and ask for input along the way. This will ensure alignment with your organizational goals. Start with a pilot program instead of a bigger audience to test your ideas and gather feedback for refinement. Choose a hands-on approach yourself in the process to gain firsthand experience and insights. Asking for continuous feedback from your participants will help with adaptability and improvement along the way. Reflect on your experiences throughout the process. Communicate your vision and show the progress students are making to gain the support and enthusiasm from colleagues and stakeholders. Don’t give up if your plan fails or has flaws. Stay committed to the goal of creating positive change. Implementing innovation plans within your organizations will increase the growth and success of your students.
​
References:
​
Conant, Doug. (2023, February 3). 52 Thought-Provoking Quotes on Managing Change Effectively. Indeed. Retrieved April 15, 2024, from https://www.indeed.com/career-advice/career-development/quotes-on-managing-change
Dweck, C. (2016). Mindset: The new psychology of success. New York, NY. Penguin Random House.
​
Harapnuik, D., Thibodeaux, T., & Cummings, C.. (2018). Choice, Ownership, and Voice through Authentic Learning COVA. Creative Commons License.
​
Sinek, S. (2014, March, 3). Start with why: Ted talk short edited. . Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IPYeCltXpxw
​
Thomas, D., & Brown, J. S. (2011). A new culture of learning: Cultivating the imagination for a world of constant change. Lexington, KY: CreateSpace.
ADL Visual
My ADL Journey:
​
"Enjoy the journey and try to get better every day. And don't lose the passion and the love for what you do." - Nadia Comaneci
​
Each course in the ADL program has been instrumental in my journey of learning and growth as an educator. Through each course, I have gained confidence in utilizing digital tools not only for my learning but also for enhancing my students' learning experiences. I have developed the ability to effectively share this new knowledge and skills with others through leadership opportunities. Reflecting on the program's principles and course objectives, the transformation from where I started to where I am now is incredible. The unity among all the courses has been remarkable, each complementing the others and contributing to the progression of this journey.
​
EDLD 5303: Applying Educational Technology
In this course, I created my eportfolio which houses all of my growth throughout this program. By building and incorporating new elements I was able to establish my identity as a digital learner and leader. I started with a foundation in this first course and have added more content, including sections such as "About Me", certifications & contact information. We were also asked to form a collaborative group during this course which I am still part of. I am so happy to have kept this group of ladies the entire program!
​
EDLD 5305: Disruptive Innovation in Education
Innovation is the driving force behind progress and advancement. In this course, I was pushed to create an innovation project, which I accomplished by designing an innovation plan. I verified the effectiveness of my plan by completing a literature review. This course pushed me to create change within my organization and made me realize that no change is too small to make a positive impact.
​
EDLD 5304: Leading Organizational Change
After being given the opportunity and the idea to create change, I recognized the necessity of acquiring the skills to go through with my innovation plan. It became evident that a thorough understanding of "why," "how," and "what" goals is crucial. Leading change requires knowledge of how to influence others, execute plans, and have crucial conversations with those involved.
​
EDLD 5302: Concepts of Educational Technology
In my learning manifesto, I nurtured a growth mindset, expanded my professional learning networks, and delved into the learning process. I took charge of my learning journey by embracing COVA principles and discovered my unique voice while exploring concepts of educational technology.
​
EDLD 5389: Developing Effective Professional Learning
After creating my innovation plan, I designed an effective professional learning session to communicate and advocate for my proposed idea. I focused on implementing my innovation plan to create authentic and active professional learning. I started with a Call to Action, followed by a professional learning outline that discussed the details, duration, and needs of my audience. Recognizing the importance of learning for educators allowed me to engage in learning and leadership roles.
​
EDLD 5313: Creating Significant Learning Environments
Creating Significant Learning Environments (CSLE) requires engagement, collaboration, a growth mindset, COVA, and much more. When creating these environments, they are shaped by my learning philosophy. By aligning outcomes with ambitious goals and creating a backward design I am able to empower students to be active participants in their learning process. When I incorporate technology into these settings, it's crucial to ensure I make sure it's a meaningful integration.
​
EDLD 5315: Assessing Digital Learning and Instruction
Being a skilled educator and innovator involves evaluating the effectiveness of classroom strategies. Are students actively participating? Are they making significant progress in their learning? What specific concepts are they not understanding? While some techniques provide immediate insights, others demand careful analysis. By assessing digital learning through my action research I can embrace this approach, allowing me to assess the method. Drawing from the findings, I as an educator, can develop strategies for improvement.
​
EDLD 5317: Resources for Digital Environments
Exploring and assessing environments and resources is essential. With the growing amount of digital tools, teachers must identify those that truly enhance student learning. As leaders, part of our role involves exploring the practical application and educational benefits of these resources. In this course, I discovered my voice and passion by creating a publication that explored the fundamentals of ePortfolios and how they can be seamlessly incorporated into any curriculum. I also had the privilege of creating a podcast with my collaborative group that discussed educational technology teaching and learning practices in the 21st century.
​
EDLD 5318: Instructional Design in Online Learning
Designing instruction is a routine task for most educators. Yet, designing online instruction presents distinct challenges. While the teaching concepts remain constant, the absence of direct instructor guidance introduces unique issues. In this course, I successfully developed an online learning module for my Graphic Design students, designed for implementation in the upcoming academic year. Leveraging our district's Learning Management System (LMS), I created the instructional design and discussed how I would implement it. I sought feedback from both my colleagues and students so that I could refine and improve the course content.
​
EDLD 5320: Synthesis of Digital Learning and Leadership
Integrating all elements learned in this program has helped build effective learning, leadership, and teaching practices. With this new found knowledge I have evolved into both a proficient digital learner and a capable digital leader. This course provided an opportunity to reflect on the numerous achievements during my ADL program journey. I am appreciative of the opportunities and growth it will continue to provide me in the future. I'm looking back saying, "Look how far I've come!" (Fearless Soul, 2023).
References:
Comaneci, N. (n.d.). Journey Quotes - BrainyQuote. Brainy Quote. Retrieved April 24, 2024, from https://www.brainyquote.com/topics/journey-quotes
​
Fearless Soul. (2023, September 19). Look How Far I've Come. YouTube. Retrieved April 24, 2024, from